New York · 2026 list
10 Best Gourmet Chocolate Shops in New York (2026 List)
Out of 47 gourmet chocolate shops we track in New York, these 10 have the strongest weighted Google ratings right now, led by Stick With Me in New York at 4.9. The picks span New York, Warwick, Brooklyn, New Hyde Park and Hudson and more.
Want the full list instead of the top 10? See all 289 chocolate shops in New York, ranked and filterable by city.
Advertisement
At a glance
| # | Shop | City | Rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Stick With Me | New York | 4.9 | 503 |
| 2 | Candy Apple Shoppe | Warwick | 4.9 | 260 |
| 3 | Chocolat Moderne | New York | 4.9 | 232 |
| 4 | Borough Chocolates | Brooklyn | 4.9 | 103 |
| 5 | Sundae Palace | New Hyde Park | 4.9 | 64 |
| 6 | Vasilow's Confectionery Inc | Hudson | 4.9 | 63 |
| 7 | Valrhona Collection | Brooklyn | 4.8 | 34 |
| 8 | Andy’s Candies | Victor | 4.9 | 15 |
| 9 | Antoinette's Sweets Inc. | Depew | 4.7 | 881 |
| 10 | Aigner Chocolates | Forest Hills | 4.7 | 415 |
The list
-
Stick With Me leads the list with a 4.9 average from 503 reviews on Google. Google describes it as: "Tiny chocolate shop selling handmade bonbons with sophisticated fillings & shiny, marbleized shells." Its Google category points to truffles and ice cream. 91% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 7 PM daily.
- Phone
- +1 646-918-6336
- Website
- swmsweets.com
- Hours
- Mon to Sun 12 to 7 PM
-
Close behind is Candy Apple Shoppe with a 4.9 average from 260 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to artisan, candy and gifts. 93% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Mondays.
- Phone
- +1 845-986-0089
- Website
- candyappleshoppe.com
- Hours
- Mon ClosedTue to Fri 11 AM to 6 PMSat 10 AM to 6 PMSun 10 AM to 5 PM
-
At number 3 is Chocolat Moderne with a 4.9 average from 232 reviews on Google. Google describes it as: "Sweets like truffles, chocolate bars & caramels are featured at this upscale shop in 9th-floor digs." Its Google category points to artisan and truffles. 94% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Sundays.
- Phone
- +1 212-229-4797
- Website
- chocolatmoderne.com
- Hours
- Mon to Sat 12 to 6 PMSun Closed
-
Next up is Borough Chocolates with a 4.9 average from 103 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to artisan, hot chocolate and candy. 94% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Mondays and Tuesdays.
- Phone
- Not listed
- Website
- boroughchocolates.com
- Hours
- Mon to Tue ClosedWed to Sat 12 to 6 PMSun 12 to 5 PM
-
Sundae Palace comes in at number 5 with a 4.9 average from 64 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to artisan. 92% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Sundays.
- Phone
- +1 516-354-6363
- Website
- thesundaepalace.com
- Hours
- Mon 10 AM to 5 PMTue 10 AM to 6 PMWed 10 AM to 5 PMThu 10 AM to 6 PMFri to Sat 10 AM to 5 PMSun Closed
-
Vasilow's Confectionery Inc holds its place here with a 4.9 average from 63 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to artisan and candy. 90% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Mondays.
- Phone
- +1 518-828-2717
- Website
- vasilows.com
- Hours
- Mon ClosedTue to Wed 10 AM to 5 PMThu to Fri 10 AM to 6 PMSat 10 AM to 5 PMSun 11 AM to 4 PM
-
Close behind is Valrhona Collection with a 4.8 average from 34 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to artisan. 94% of its Google reviews are five stars. Hours are not listed, so call before you go.
- Phone
- Not listed
- Website
- valrhona-collection.us
- Hours
- Not listed. Call ahead.
-
At number 8 is Andy’s Candies with a 4.9 average from 15 reviews on Google. Its Google category points to artisan and candy. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 8 PM on Mondays.
- Phone
- +1 585-223-5712
- Website
- andyscandies.com
- Hours
- Mon to Sat 10 AM to 8 PMSun 11 AM to 6 PM
-
Next up is Antoinette's Sweets Inc. with a 4.7 average from 881 reviews on Google. Google describes it as: "Iconic sweet shop turning out a wide variety of candies & chocolates, plus homemade ice cream." Its Google category points to artisan, candy and gifts. 81% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is closed Sundays and stays open until 9 PM every day it opens.
- Phone
- +1 716-684-2376
- Website
- antoinettesbuffalo.com
- Hours
- Mon to Sat 11 AM to 9 PMSun Closed
-
Aigner Chocolates comes in at number 10 with a 4.7 average from 415 reviews on Google. Google describes it as: "Longstanding family-owned sweet shop known for gourmet Austrian chocolate made on the premises." Its Google category points to hot chocolate, candy and ice cream. 87% of its Google reviews are five stars. It is open seven days a week and stays open until 8 PM on Thursdays.
- Phone
- +1 718-544-1850
- Website
- aignerchocolates.com
- Hours
- Mon to Wed 10 AM to 6 PMThu to Sat 10 AM to 8 PMSun 10 AM to 6 PM
How we picked these
Every shop here comes from public Google business data, and qualifies because Google tags them as chocolate artisans, they sell truffles or bonbons, or their Google description calls their chocolate handmade, small-batch, artisan or gourmet.
We rank by weighted rating so a handful of five-star reviews cannot outrank years of consistent ones. Hours and phone numbers come straight from each listing, and anything missing is marked as missing.
Questions
What is the best gourmet chocolate shop in New York?
Stick With Me in New York tops this list with a 4.9 average from 503 Google reviews.
How was this list ranked?
By a weighted Google rating: each shop's average is pulled toward the overall average until it has enough reviews to stand on its own.
A shop qualifies when Google tags them as chocolate artisans, they sell truffles or bonbons, or their Google description calls their chocolate handmade, small-batch, artisan or gourmet. No business pays to appear.
Where can I see every gourmet chocolate shop in New York?
The New York chocolate shop directory lists all 289 shops we track there, with filters, a city breakdown and an open-now toggle.